Charmed (The Original Series) Unpopular Opinion, I actually like neighbour Dan. I am aware that back in the show's original run Dan wasn't very popular back in season 2. And I first watched Charmed back in 2005/2006, so my early Charmed memories are that of season 7 and season 8. It wasn't until I was 8 that I started watching the full eight ...Favourite season: 5, has one of the best episodes of the whole show. directly followed by season 4. Season 1: Deja vu all over again (I absolutely love the ending scene on the stairs in front of the manor) Season 2: Ms. Hellfire of course. Season 3: Blinded by the whitelighter / all hell breaks loos are even for me.While not a HUGE sale, it is on sale for $156 and if you do not have the complete series on bluray, I suggest getting this one compared to the US edition as you get more bang for your buck. The US edition does not have the unaired pilot and this comes with a new BoS (in German though) along with mini posters/map and in a nice box.Like the others have said: it isn't problematic for a character to have problematic views (misogyny, misandry, homophobia, racism, whatevs) so much as whether your show wants you to sympathise with those views.. In this case, Grams was a misandrist for sure- but the narrative made it clear (mostly through other characters reacting) that it was a wrong view to haveSeason 2, Episode 1 - Phoebe & Dan. There's a scene in the second half of the episode when Dan goes over the manor and Phoebe opens the door. There's general chit chat, and he gives her a bottle of wine to thank her for chatting with Jenny. The way the whole scene plays out, makes me wonder - was Dan originally meant to be a love interest for ...Nov 28, 2018. Nov 6, 2018. Mel and Maggie Vera suffer a shock when their mother dies suddenly, but before they have time to heal from their loss, another surprise shows up on their doorstep in the ...r/charmed • "A demon has been spotted downdown, quick guys, put on your demon hunting shoes for when we chase them" ...IKate17. •. Phoebe and Cole were the best part of Charmed IMO. From the time they met to before he became the source were the best episodes of the series. I was devastated when they took him out, but I guess he left to get a big part in Nip/Tuck. The series was never the same after he left.A Witch's Tail, Part 2 - Season 5 Episode 2. Summary: Paige, Leo and Piper try to track the mermaid Phoebe, who is eventually captured by the demon who made the deal with the sea-hag for immortality. Meanwhile, Piper is worried about fighting while she is pregnant. (from imdb) Original airdate - September 22, 2002.Overall Season 7 worked for me. The Avatars promised utopia but at a price of everyone's soul. And it turns out that Good needs Evil to create a balance in Life. And that life w/o suffering is pointless. And I absolutely adored Kyle, tormented by the deaths of his parents as a child and obsessed with revenge.It was about Alyssa having fun and living vicariously through Phoebe, making her famous (which is just stupid as a charmed one to not keep a lower profile), overly sexy (don’t even get me started on the sexy baby talk), extremely selfish, and desperate to go on dates/find her next husband/get pregnant, even though she was barely 30.onthefitz123. •. Now that's an interesting one actually - in the episode Phoebe is inspired by Lady Godiva's ride, and in order to protest people getting annoyed by breastfeeding in public decides to do the same, and it's a "why do women always have to take off their clothes to make a point" thing.The mods of r/Charmed are very excited to present the very first Best of r/Charmed Awards for 2022! This has been an incredible year for the sub and we want to give back to you - the members that make this subreddit and fandom so special! Without your continued participation, we wouldn't have the great community we have now!Cole was very smart which was half of his power imo. He was ridiculously powerful, Cole nearly killed the source back in season 4 only for the oracle to sacrifice herself and save him. And that was just Cole, as far as it is suggested in the series he would have been even stronger as Belthazor.Codebox42. • 4 yr. ago. While Phoebe is my most disliked character in the show, Piper hands down is the biggest Karen of them all. Season 8 showcased the worst of this. (namely the Battle of the Hexes episode) Phoebe has her fair share of Karen moments (namely in Season 7 when she goes all feminist and sexist again men) but Piper is just full ...Charmed is a strange mix between deathly serious and kooky comedy. Over its long run, the show has constructed an elaborate good vs. evil fantasy world populated by elders, avatars, seers, and demons. But even with some heavily dramatic content involving the death of family members, Charmed remains fundamentally a silly show -- often with weak storylines and poor acting.A pholder about r/charmed. All; Communities; Influencers; r/charmed. Page 2 of about 1,175 results (0.14 seconds) Is it just me or Piper seriously lacked empathy taking Paige away? 1mo ⋅ thorusaurus ⋅ r/charmed. ADVERTISEMENT. damn piper is definitely the most beautiful of the sisters especially in this picture wow. ...Robert Burns, widely regarded as Scotland’s national poet, is celebrated for his remarkable contribution to literature. His works have left an indelible mark on the world of poetry...Her strongest season is season 4, IMO. I think she properly adjusted to the changing tones of Charmed. Charmed became more comedic and Rose served us comedy. 26. Lordmilanwavy • 1 yr. ago. Yes Season 4 was the best of Rose’s acting in the series but Season 6 was best character development for Paige. 2.IKate17. •. Phoebe and Cole were the best part of Charmed IMO. From the time they met to before he became the source were the best episodes of the series. I was devastated when they took him out, but I guess he left to get a big part in Nip/Tuck. The series was never the same after he left.So if you're not already familiar, Cole is finally vanquished in season 5's "Centennial Charmed" episode. However, in "Seven Year Witch" (season 7), Cole reappears for the first time since his official death as a spirit or ghost eternally trapped in a "cosmic void between life and death", otherwise known as limbo.oh you'd be surprised how often the production insisted they didn't wear bras and nipples were visible through their clothes. it was a really cringey way to try and get hetero male viewers. You'll probably start noticing it now. It's curious how Holly never seemed to have this trope unlike her co-stars.There are a lot of them available to read online on openlibrary.org. Not all of them though, unfortunately. they were not written by constance m burge. the best one id say is whispers from the past. there are some big inconsistencies (even for charmed) in some of the books set after season 4 like phoebe having energy balls and such.Welcome to r/Degrassi! Home of all things relating to the Degrassi franchise past, present and future! It has spanned five series since 1979, most notably Degrassi Junior High, Degrassi High and Degrassi: The Next Generation. If you are new or want to know where to watch, please read the pinned post "Newcomer's Guide To Degrassi".The NSS theory : drawing the n*pple short straw (nsfw) Charmed on Netflix was great. Binge watching was fun and made it easy to notice things. Actually started playing NSS, a game we made up to guess who had to wear the thin shirt braless that day. Because then it was so constant that it got weird.Be Careful What You Witch For - Season 2 Episode 22. Summary: A Genie, employed by a Dragon Warlock to steal the Halliwells' powers, offers to grant each sister one wish for whatever they most desire. (from imdb) Original airdate - May 18, 2000. Written by - Brad Kern & Zach Estrin & Chris Levinson. Directed by - Shannen Doherty.S4 Episode:15 Marry- go - Round. Currently watching this episode and the way Phoebe acts in this episode makes me so mad. First off it’s annoying that she’s having this big wedding when her and Cole don’t work. So I’m assuming Piper is the one paying for it all, which in completely unfair.Welcome to the r/Charmed episode re-watch discussions! Each week, we'll be revisiting two episodes of the series as a subreddit. Threads will be posted on Wednesdays each week, as the first season aired on Wednesday nights. Catch up on your own time during the week and pop into the threads for discussion!r/charmed. r/charmed. The subreddit for the 1998 WB drama Charmed Members Online. Shannen reveals how she thinks Prue and Paige would have got along and her, Holly & Rose would be open to a rebootThe sound effects of Charmed. The sound effects of the show were one of the best things and most consistent of the show. All the different sound effects for the powers added so much. In Morality Bites the slight change to Prue/Pipers powers sound effects is my fave. Pipers sound effect is doubled to further insinuate how her powers grew.r/charmed. r/charmed. The subreddit for the 1998 WB drama Charmed Members Online. Still can never get over how Paige (Rose McGowan) can pull of both hair colors so flawlessly! ...Just found that Charmed is free on peacock and I'm about to delve into season 1 again…. Archived post. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Keep in mind, any streaming service (whether it's Netflix, Amazon Prime, Peacock, etc.) will be using different songs, than what you're used to hearing, from the DvDs.She told the producers something to the effect of, "You have Piper and Leo, but you can also give Alyssa a man to deal with, too.". This led to the introduction of Cole's character. That's why Prue has little to no major dating prospects later on in the show, and she becomes a lone wolf, Super Witch-type character. 85.Alex and Ani Initial R Charm Bangle expresses your identity and individuality. Crafted in our Shiny Silver finish, this beautiful keepsake bangle features a letter R charm. Our expandable bangle adjusts from 2" to 3.5" in width. Innovative, patented, and completely original technology ensures a customized fit of this elegant bangle bracelet.currently rewatching charmed and i just finished the last episode of season 3 but i had to write here something that just confused me.. In the last episode, prue and piper kill the demon shanks in daylight on the streets and later on he appears in front of the hospital and they „kill" him again. Everything went downhill, everyone knows they ...All Halliwell's Eve - Season 3 Episode 4. Summary: The sisters are sent back in time on Halloween to save a baby from being born into the clutches of evil. Meanwhile, Leo and Darryl are left to keep the grimlocks at bay until the sisters return. (from imdb) Original airdate - October 26, 2000. Written by - Sheryl J. Anderson.All Hell Breaks Loose - Season 3 Episode 22. Summary: Prue, Phoebe and Piper are exposed on live television as witches. In an effort to undo what has been done, the Charmed Ones strike a deal with the dark side to turn back time and reverse their sudden fame, unfortunately this deal comes with a terrible price. (from imdb)Lastly, she was a writing catalyst to help Phoebe mature a bit while Jenny filled that young reckless gap before diving into Phoebe's more adult driven arc with Cole in season 3. Edit: Brad Kern, not Daniel. Idk why my brain did that, I think I read DanLeo too many times in a row in regards to the writer disputes and misremembered his name as ...Prue staying would've killed the show. If they had kept Shannen instead and let Alyssa walked Charmed wouldn't have lasted past season 5. Piper's SLs would've been stunted and Paige would've been too stubborn and carefree for Prue and that wouldn't have worked either. Firing her allowed Piper and Paige to grow as characters.Both Piper and Phoebe are insufferably irritating in Seasons 5-8, but I'm gonna have to give the edge to Season 3-8 Phoebe. She's easily the worst Charmed One by far. This is a sad case because in Seasons 1-2 I LOVED Phoebe, in fact I dare call Season 2 Phoebe Charmed's best character. Her free spirited nature, comedic lines and love of ...Duhallower. •. It’s the same reason why the 2003-2010 tv show Cold Case was never released on DVD or Blu-Ray and didn’t appear on any streaming platforms until 2020. The licensing of all the contemporaneous music from each episode (which is a strength of the show) was only secured for tv distribution.Charmed: Created by Constance M. Burge, Jessica O'Toole, Amy Rardin, Jennie Snyder Urman. With Melonie Diaz, Sarah Jeffery, Rupert Evans, Madeleine Mantock. Follows the lives of three sisters who, after the tragic death of their mother, discover they are powerful witches.Nov 28, 2018. Nov 6, 2018. Mel and Maggie Vera suffer a shock when their mother dies suddenly, but before they have time to heal from their loss, another surprise shows up on their doorstep in the ...Charmed is an American fantasy drama television series developed by Jennie Snyder Urman, Jessica O'Toole, and Amy Rardin. It is a reboot of the WB series of the same …The Good, The Bad And The Cursed - Season 3 Episode 14. Summary: Phoebe somehow becomes psychically and physically linked with the violent past of an Old West ghost town complete with horses, petticoats, cowboys and six-shooters and Prue must go back in time to save her sister from a horrifying fate. (from imdb) Original airdate - February 15 ...OP • 3 yr. ago. Koch Media Home Entertainment will release all 178 episodes of the original cult series "Charmed: Zauberhafte Hexen" (USA 1998-2006) for the first time completely in HD as a complete edition on Blu-ray. The Book of Shadows contains 40 Blu-ray discs with an additional over 214 minutes of bonus material, including a making-of ...Thoughts on Marry-Go-Round (Season 4, Episode 15) Out of all the wedding episode Phoebe's is easily the worst one. While Piper wasn't spectacular in her's I could at least forgive it because of the plot with Prue and the speech at the end. But in Marry-Go-Round Phoebe is a complete wench from beginning to end, how she treats Paige is horrible. oh man, of the ones I have read (which isn't all of them), there's a few: Mist and Stone. Mystic Knoll. Something Wiccan This Way Comes. The Warren Witches. Inherit the Witch. Kiss of Darkness. Truth and Consequences. Mirror Image. Did anyone else notice this? Okay so I'm always watching the reruns of Charmed. Anyway, I have just watched the episode where they go back in time to save their ancestor Melinda and help her be born. There is a part in the episode where Phoebe looks into a barrel to see that her true love's name begins with a "C"...At the beginning of the episode, we see Prue's astral self attempting to telekinetically move a fork, however it fails. So that's the slow running theme throughout the episode is Prue's struggle with her secondary ability, or at least having more control and use of her primary ability with her Astral power. She becomes an empath and vanquishes ...Unrelated, but Phoebe was so pretty in season 2. Prue had depth in Season 1 and 2, then in season 3 she became reckless and her ego was unbearable. She went headfirst into danger all the time because no one was as good a witch as her. I get her.Alphabet Charm Letter Beads,A-Z Letter Initial Spacer,Solid Woman' Sterling Silver DIY Charm (R) 4.3 out of 5 stars. 138. $12.99 $ 12. 99. FREE delivery Tue, Mar 19 on $35 of items shipped by Amazon. Only 16 left in stock - order soon.Lindsay MacDonald May 17, 2018, 11:39 a.m. PT. The Charmed reboot currently in the works at The CW has been a polarizing project for fans of the original show, but now that the pilot has ...When it comes to Charmed and its three bewitching stars, anything seems possible. Consider this: Without much publicity -- certainly lacking the media blitz given to the WB's other freshman drama, Felicity -- the enchanting show about a trio of sisters who discover they are witches scored the highest ratings for a debut in the network's history.I'm not normally one to download books or comics, but none of my book store will order in the volumes of the Charmed comics, SO, has anyone every… 5. Season 5: The Day the Magic Died. All magic is lost from the world. Demoms take taxis. Geese and a unicorn run around the manor all while piper is getting ready to have wyatt. Easily one of the best episodes of the entire series. 6. Season 6: Crimes and Witch Demeanors. Spoiler tags are not required, but suggested if the discussion starts to move towards a future plot/episode/etc. A Wrong Day's Journey Into Right - Season 6 Episode 20. Summary: A mysterious "demon" is using the Charmed Ones' spells and potions to vanquish demons. Meanwhile, Paige is using magic for her own personal gain so that she can relax ... Both Piper and Phoebe are insufferably irritating in Seasons 5-8, but I'm gonna have to give the edge to Season 3-8 Phoebe. She's easily the worst Charmed One by far. This is a sad case because in Seasons 1-2 I LOVED Phoebe, in fact I dare call Season 2 Phoebe Charmed's best character. Her free spirited nature, comedic lines and love of ... Welcome to the r/Charmed episode re-watch discussions! Each week, we'll be revisiting two episodes of the series as a subreddit. Threads will be posted on Wednesdays each week, as the first season aired on Wednesday nights. Catch up on your own time during the week and pop into the threads for discussion! Streaming availability of the show ...Let’s talk about Prue. I love Prue to death but I wish she was more cautious. I’m on a rewatch and I’m noticing that Prue is very much act now ask later and it’s very risky. There’s no planning, minimal book consults, and in this episode (Season 3, Sin Francisco) she went looking for evil. It’s just very not smart.As of 2015, Country Charm cast iron electric stoves can be purchased on eBay. WorthPoint is a resource website that provides a comprehensive list of “sold” and “for sale” listings ...A Change In Clothes. Rewatching season one, I noticed that the ladies dress more conservative than they do in later seasons. Prue's work attire at Buckland's is more appropriate and professional than the clothing she starts wearing there in season two. And Phoebe's wardrobe is normal. She hadn't started wearing all the weird outfits yet.Piper was overwhelmed. She'd had a taste of being the "safety net" before, with her employment helping the family financially. She's a peacemaker, a mediator. She's used to stopping the world from crashing down around her. I just don't think she could stop it from crashing inside.currently rewatching charmed and i just finished the last episode of season 3 but i had to write here something that just confused me.. In the last episode, prue and piper kill the demon shanks in daylight on the streets and later on he appears in front of the hospital and they „kill" him again. Everything went downhill, everyone knows they ...Initial A-Z Letter Charm Bead, Alphabet Charms Rose Gold, Authentic 925 Sterling Silver Charms fit Pandora Charm Bracelets, Necklace, Circle Dangle Charm for Women, Girls, Sparkling Clear Stone. 362. $1999. FREE delivery Mon, Mar 4 on $35 of items shipped by Amazon. Or fastest delivery Thu, Feb 29. r/charmed. r/charmed. The subreddit for the 1998 WB drama Charmed Members Online. Watching this as a kid VS watching this now after having worked in Customer Service ... Thanks to this person's idea, it's my new headcannon, now.. Prue, Piper and Phoebe survive the events of S3E22 "All Hell Breaks Loose". They need to rescue Paige, from Shax because the Source found out about her, and doesn't want the …The Elders. Darryl (Temporarily in 6/7) Last but not the least GIDEON. Gideon is the one I hated the most for what he put baby Wyatt through. He litterally traumatised a child to a point where 2 year old Wyatt attempted suicide because of what happened.In a way I sometimes like to imagine that the show is five seasons long, with the final season consisting of Centennial Charmed, the S5 finale, Chris-Crossed, S6E14-19, the last 3 S6 episodes, Cheaper by the Coven, Someone to Witch Over Me, the Utopia duo, The Seven Year Witch, Something Wicca This Way Goes, Still Charmed and Kicking, Rewitched and the final 2 S8 episodes.There should be two available for purchase on the Kindle store: The War On Witches by Paul Ruditis and Let Gorgons Be Gorgons by Paul Ruditis. However those two books are set after the events of both the TV show and the comics. You should be able to find several of the completely out of print novels on open library to borrow.r/charmed. r/charmed. The subreddit for the 1998 WB drama Charmed Members Online. Best thing this character ever did in the show. *Prue Halliwell*While not a HUGE sale, it is on sale for $156 and if you do not have the complete series on bluray, I suggest getting this one compared to the US edition as you get more bang for your buck. The US edition does not have the unaired pilot and this comes with a new BoS (in German though) along with mini posters/map and in a nice box.At first at the end of the episode yes, he killed Prue, but after Demon "Tempus" turned back the time, most people found out, that the three were witches and one of these psychic ill women, who want to became a part of the Charmed Ones, shot Prue as she used her powers, to throw her out of the house.Charmed is an American fantasy drama television series developed by Jennie Snyder Urman. This series is a reboot of The WB series of the same name, created by Constance M. Burge, which originally aired from 1998 to 2006. Charmed follows the lives of three sisters — Macy, Mel and Maggie Vera — who, after the tragic death of their mother ...As of 2015, Country Charm cast iron electric stoves can be purchased on eBay. WorthPoint is a resource website that provides a comprehensive list of “sold” and “for sale” listings ...Least favourites from the Paige era: I hope Lucky Charmed (5x17), Nymphs Just Wanna Have Fun (5x19), The Power of Three Blondes (6x04) and Prince Charmed (6x12) all have a special place in hell. The season 5 ones are the worst kind of filler, bland, boring, unambitious, creatively bankrupt. Ur sleepin if u havent. In the audio commentary for The Craft, the director says that Aaron Spelling came to him and asked him for the name of one of the songs used in the movie. That song turned out be “How Soon is Now”. So, yes, Charmed did take a lot of things from The Craft. its worse for me. i was born in '94 and the first time i ever ... Charmed revival series. Entire Series. Who would it if they created a new Charmed show that continues from where the original Charmed left off (excluding the comics of course). So will be a new Charmed but it won't be a reboot because it will share continuity with the original series. And it will feature all children of the Charmed Ones.Charmed - Apple TV. Available on TNT, Pluto TV, Peacock, Prime Video, Hulu, Sling TV. A group of sisters discover they are witches. Luckily for the world, they're … So if you’re not already familiar, Cole is finally vanquished in season 5’s “Centennial Charmed” episode. However, in “Seven Year Witch” (season 7), Cole reappears for the first time since his official death as a spirit or ghost eternally trapped in a “cosmic void between life and death”, otherwise known as limbo. 8. Sort by: Skulenta. • 3 yr. ago. People always blame Billie or the budget for how bad season eight is, when it was pretty much doomed from the beginning. The Charmed Ones have zero interest in fighting demons or helping innocents at this point. Paige even fought with her own whitelighter instinct pushing her to save innocents. 6.CW Charmed (2018) Reboot Cancelled - Megathread. One of our rules here is that all discussion of the 2018 reboot should be directed to r/CharmedCW, but in light of today's news of it's cancellation, as per TVline, please use this megathread to discuss it. There will be no other threads on the subject allowed.THIS ☝️, I've always wondered if the baby was originally Phoebe and Cole's, and that's why the seer gave Phoebe the tonic so that it would strip the child of its charmed one heritage. 7. enamoredandhammered • 8 mo. ago. I never thought of that. That's a whole other layer of guilt for Phoebe with the context of the seers tonic causing the ...r/charmed. r/charmed. The subreddit for the 1998 WB drama Charmed Members Online. The grandfather clock is the true villain, the repair costs alone 😭r/charmed • "A demon has been spotted downdown, quick guys, put on your demon hunting shoes for when we chase them" ...Piper's lack of her Molecular Immobilisation power was another victim of the show's budget cuts in later seasons. My take is Piper uses her freezing power less as it's less effective against demons. But she does use it sometimes. Less expensive to blow shit up. 2009 Piper freeze a whole city block/area. Looked so cool.
Cole's Storyline. Cole. i know cole is a fan favorite, he's one of mine, as well. and recently ive been rewatching charmed and i just cant get over how great of a character he is. the push and pull of good and evil for him, his relationship to phoebe, to paige and piper, to everyone... i just cant get over it. i don't particularly mind how cole .... Rachel brockman fanfix leak
With Dan it was. Jenny knocks on door, gets let in, begs to use phone, Dan walks in says "Jenny", all 3 sisters say "whoa", introduction happens, Jenny runs out, Dan says bye and walks out closing the door behind him, Phoebe turns around and says "I saw him fiiiiirst"….65 upvotes 9. 84 votes, 36 comments. 28K subscribers in the charmed community. The subreddit for the 1998 WB drama Charmed.Prue staying would've killed the show. If they had kept Shannen instead and let Alyssa walked Charmed wouldn't have lasted past season 5. Piper's SLs would've been stunted and Paige would've been too stubborn and carefree for Prue and that wouldn't have worked either. Firing her allowed Piper and Paige to grow as characters.r/charmed. r/charmed. The subreddit for the 1998 WB drama Charmed Members Online. Solar eclipse in charmed 🌑 ☀️ 2. upvotes ...The Charmed Wiki is a database that anyone can edit about the hit tv-series Charmed starring Shannen Doherty, Holly Marie Combs, Alyssa Milano and Rose McGowan.jan0009683. • 3 yr. ago. The biggest difference I ever saw in a Charmed script was the ending to Long Live The Queen, which originally had Phoebe apologising to Piper and Paige for her actions and featured a discussion about what to do with the Source's baby. 12. EverlastingUnis.You can be The Source but watch this Charmed One conquer. Prue gets corrupted and becomes the true Queen of the Underworld. Shannen Doherty plays 'The Devil' in one of her new films and looks far more frightful than The Source we got. The Source of all evil Queen of the Damned Queen of all evil. Actors.r/charmed • Does it annoy anyone else that their actual hairstyles didn't match their "fake selves" ones? Phoebe and page have their hair tied up, their fake selves don't. Piper has her hair down, her fake self has her's tied up.Probably it was the writing, but the actor didn't help. 5. Naive-Plate9143. • 2 yr. ago • Edited 2 yr. ago. It's Paige for me, always huffin and puffin. 4. Cordially_Cordi. • 2 yr. ago. The worst acting performance by any of the main actors was Aylssa when she was playing Paige in that body swap episode.Pandora jewelry charms have become increasingly popular in recent years, offering a unique and personalized way to express individual style. With countless options available, it ca...r/charmed. r/charmed. The subreddit for the 1998 WB drama Charmed Members Online. People who Bash OG Charmed as Bad (esp its writing) and Compare it to Buffy and moderns like Supernatural and esp the CW Remake don't Understand how TERRIBLE ongoing mainstream TV Fiction was all in all back in the 90s Charmed is an American fantasy drama television series developed by Jennie Snyder Urman. This series is a reboot of The WB series of the same name, created by Constance M. Burge, which originally aired from 1998 to 2006. All the while we see Phoebe at her darkest and cruelest with the growing threat of their child being born. Then towards the second half of season 5, we start to see Phoebe struggle especially when it comes to killing her sisters so the struggle as seen in the episode ' Long Live The Queen' could play out resulting in Phoebe turning her back on ...Prue staying would’ve killed the show. If they had kept Shannen instead and let Alyssa walked Charmed wouldn’t have lasted past season 5. Piper’s SLs would’ve been stunted and Paige would’ve been too stubborn and carefree for Prue and that wouldn’t have worked either. Firing her allowed Piper and Paige to grow as characters..